From: kengrimes <ken@kengrimes.com>
Date: Sat, 21 Apr 2018 02:39:59 +0000 (-0700)
Subject: Why not use Hugo's org parser?
X-Git-Url: https://git.kengrimes.com/?p=kengrimes.com%2Fcontent.git;a=commitdiff_plain;h=1ddd694c976a3f69f4a83097fa5bac61c0037947

Why not use Hugo's org parser?
---

diff --git a/content.org b/content.org
index 16c3f5d..bd49824 100644
--- a/content.org
+++ b/content.org
@@ -644,6 +644,31 @@ It will export as the Summary value in front-matter
 To do this on a per-heading basis, simply add the
 ~:EXPORT_HUGO_FRONT_MATTER_KEY_REPLACE:~ property to a heading's property block,
 and the replacements will only occur within that heading.
+
+**** Why not use Hugo's internal Org parser?
+It's true that Hugo has an internal Org parser that is well maintained. It
+provides this as an alternative to markdown files. You may wonder, then, why
+someone would use Org mode to export to markdown instead of just letting Hugo
+parse the Org files itself. The answer is two-fold:
+1. Hugo's Org format is currently less feature complete than markdown, so
+   exporting from Org mode to the Hugo Org Format would limit potential output.
+2. Org mode is a lot more than just a file format, and its integration with your
+   system allows all kinds of benefits you can never get out of a simple Org
+   file parser.
+Therefore, supporting the Org format in another tool will give you a superior
+text format for organizing information, but it will be crippled when compared to
+an actual Org mode implementation. Ox-hugo gives you the ability to use Org mode
+itself to generate content.
+
+If Hugo's Org parser gains parity with, or eclipses, the Blackfriday Markdown
+format currently used by Hugo, ox-hugo could certainly be used to output those
+Org-Hugo files instead of the current markdown. This would be nice because it
+would allow Org mode users to view their output content more easily, but the
+advantages of ox-hugo and a real, bona fide Org mode would still remain.
+
+So you see, Hugo's Org parser isn't really in competition with ox-hugo, it's in
+competition with the /other/ Hugo formats (e.g. markdown).
+
 *** Thanks
 Thanks to Kaushal Modi, who found this article on the googs within days of me
 posting it, for reaching out to me and providing thorough feedback and error
diff --git a/content/ox-hugo-tutorial.md b/content/ox-hugo-tutorial.md
index ebcfa37..c4f40f7 100644
--- a/content/ox-hugo-tutorial.md
+++ b/content/ox-hugo-tutorial.md
@@ -699,6 +699,34 @@ To do this on a per-heading basis, simply add the
 and the replacements will only occur within that heading.
 
 
+## Why not use Hugo's internal Org parser? {#why-not-use-hugo-s-internal-org-parser}
+
+It's true that Hugo has an internal Org parser that is well maintained. It
+provides this as an alternative to markdown files. You may wonder, then, why
+someone would use Org mode to export to markdown instead of just letting Hugo
+parse the Org files itself. The answer is two-fold:
+
+1.  Hugo's Org format is currently less feature complete than markdown, so
+    exporting from Org mode to the Hugo Org Format would limit potential output.
+2.  Org mode is a lot more than just a file format, and its integration with your
+    system allows all kinds of benefits you can never get out of a simple Org
+    file parser.
+
+Therefore, supporting the Org format in another tool will give you a superior
+text format for organizing information, but it will be crippled when compared to
+an actual Org mode implementation. Ox-hugo gives you the ability to use Org mode
+itself to generate content.
+
+If Hugo's Org parser gains parity with, or eclipses, the Blackfriday Markdown
+format currently used by Hugo, ox-hugo could certainly be used to output those
+Org-Hugo files instead of the current markdown. This would be nice because it
+would allow Org mode users to view their output content more easily, but the
+advantages of ox-hugo and a real, bona fide Org mode would still remain.
+
+So you see, Hugo's Org parser isn't really in competition with ox-hugo, it's in
+competition with the _other_ Hugo formats (e.g. markdown).
+
+
 # Thanks {#thanks}
 
 Thanks to Kaushal Modi, who found this article on the googs within days of me